Subscribe for updates
Get talent acquisition best practices, trends, and news delivered directly to your inbox.
By entering your email, you agree to receive marketing emails from JobScore
Are you struggling to consistently identify the right candidates for your company? You’re not alone. Many organizations face these challenges when it comes to recruiting. With limited resources and a busy team, every decision matters.
That’s where structured interviews come in.
A well-organized talent acquisition process is critical for organizations that need to find top talent quickly and efficiently. Structured interviews can help streamline your hiring, reduce recruiting costs, and ensure you’re hiring the best candidate for the job.
In this guide, we’ll explore how structured interviews work, why they’re so effective, and how you can start using them to improve your hiring process.
What are structured interviews?
Structured interviews are a standardized method of interviewing job candidates, where each interviewer asks the same set of questions in the same order for every candidate. These questions are designed to assess the specific skills, knowledge, and experience required for the job.
Key elements of structured interviews:
This is different from an unstructured interview, where questions may vary from candidate to candidate, often leading to inconsistent or subjective hiring decisions.
Benefits of structured interviews
Structured interviews provide several key advantages:
1
Consistency in hiring
A structured interview process helps ensure that every candidate is evaluated on the same criteria, which reduces bias and makes your hiring decisions more objective. This consistency helps you avoid making decisions based on “gut feelings” and instead focus on the actual qualifications and fit for the role.
Structured interviews also allow for multiple interviewers to be involved at each stage of the recruitment process without sacrificing consistency. Your team can maintain uniformity in how candidates are assessed when all interviewers use the same questions and scoring rubric.
2
Time efficiency
Structured interviews streamline your recruitment process so your hiring team can be more efficient.
Over half of employers make candidates go through four or more interviews, and have a process that lasts four to six weeks. This may be costing you candidates, as 32% of North American candidates that withdrew from the recruiting process said they accepted another offer from a different company. Planning your interview process and the questions you’ll ask in advance can help you eliminate unnecessary interview rounds.
3
Better candidate fit
Structured interviews are designed to hone in on the specific skills, qualifications, and traits needed for success in a particular role. By using standardized questions tied directly to the job requirements, you can better assess whether a candidate truly has the capabilities needed. This method ensures that you’re not just hiring someone who interviews well, but someone who has the right experience and skills to excel in the position.
As a result, you’re more likely to select a qualified candidate who’s a strong fit for your team. This reduces the risk of bad hires, improves retention, and boosts team performance.
4
Cost savings
Recruiting can be a costly process, particularly when bad hires result in high turnover or poor job performance. Each hiring mistake leads to additional recruiting, onboarding, and training costs—not to mention the impact on team morale and productivity.
Structured interviews help mitigate these risks by improving the quality of your hiring decisions. By using consistent, objective criteria to evaluate candidates, you’re more likely to hire someone who’s the right fit for the role and your company culture. In the long run, this leads to significant cost savings by reducing turnover and improving employee retention.
5
Improved candidate experience
Structured interviews help ensure that candidates are judged solely on their skills, qualifications, and fit for the role, rather than on personal biases or subjective impressions. By standardizing the interview process with predefined questions and objective scoring, all candidates are evaluated consistently and fairly. This creates a more equitable hiring environment and gives candidates confidence that they’re being assessed on merit.
Additionally, a well-structured interview process is more efficient and organized, which reflects positively on your company. Candidates are more likely to feel valued and be inclined to accept your job offer when they experience a smooth, professional hiring process,
6
Legal compliance
Structured interviews are a powerful tool to help protect your company from potential legal challenges. Asking all candidates the same set of questions and evaluating them using the same scoring rubric reduces the risk of unconscious bias creeping into your hiring decisions.
Additionally, a consistent interview process ensures fair and equal treatment for every applicant, helping your company comply with anti-discrimination laws. By standardizing your interviews, you can minimize legal risks while promoting a more diverse and inclusive workforce.
How to create a structured interview process
Ready to start using structured interviews? Follow these steps to design an effective structured interview process for your company.
Step 1: Define the job requirements
Start by clearly defining the job role and the core responsibilities, necessary skills, qualifications, and traits required for success in the role. Use that to create a detailed job description that outlines the competencies you’re looking for.
This step is crucial because the interview questions and evaluation criteria should be directly tied to these job requirements. A clear understanding of what you’re looking for sets the foundation for a targeted and effective hiring process.
Step 2: Develop interview questions
Next, develop a set of interview questions you can use to evaluate your candidates on the job requirements. Using behavioral interviewing questions enables candidates to share past experiences that demonstrate their skills. For example, you could ask a candidate for a customer-facing role to tell you about a time they head to deal with an angry customer.
Encourage detailed responses by using open-ended questions; yes/no questions don’t offer much insight into the candidate’s abilities.
Step 3: Design a scoring rubric
Create a scoring system to objectively evaluate candidate responses. For each interview question, consider what a strong, average, or weak response would look like. This helps interviewers stay consistent and fair when evaluating candidates.
For example:
Step 4: Train hiring managers and interviewers
Consistency is critical to the success of structured interviews, so thorough training is essential. All interviewers, from hiring managers to department leads, must understand how to follow the structured process. This includes knowing how to ask the predefined questions, use the scoring rubric effectively, and evaluate candidates objectively.
Regular interviewer training sessions can help ensure that the hiring team doesn’t deviate from the structured format or rely on subjective judgments during the job interview. By aligning everyone on the same process, you maintain consistency across interviews, reduce bias, and improve the overall quality of your hiring decisions.
Step 5: Create and send interview plans
Interview plans help ensure that each interviewer understands their role in the recruitment process and the specific questions that have been assigned to them.
Create a plan that includes interview questions, rating criteria, and tips on how to sell candidates on an opportunity. Include interview plans in your calendar events and email interview reminders so interviewers can easily access them when they meet with candidates. This organized approach not only keeps the process consistent but also equips interviewers to effectively assess and attract top talent to your company.
Common mistakes to avoid
While structured interviews offer many benefits, it’s easy to make mistakes if you’re new to the process. Avoid these common pitfalls to get the most out of your interviews.
Inconsistent implementation
One of the biggest mistakes is failing to apply the structured interview process uniformly across all candidates. If one interviewer deviates from the standardized questions, the whole process becomes inconsistent. Make sure all interviewers are on the same page.
Ignoring the scoring rubric
Structured interviews rely on objective evaluation, so it’s essential to use the scoring rubric. Interviewers may be tempted to rely on their gut feeling, but doing so can introduce bias and reduce the effectiveness of the process.
Not customizing interview questions for each role
While the interview structure should remain consistent, your questions need to be specific to the job. Using generic questions across all roles won’t help you identify the best candidates. Make sure your questions target the unique skills needed for each position.
Failing to ask follow-up questions
Even with a structured interview, it’s important to ask follow-up questions when a candidate’s initial response isn’t clear or needs elaboration. Many interviewers make the mistake of moving on too quickly.
Probing questions help you dig deeper into the candidate’s experience, clarify vague answers, and gather more detailed information. Just ensure these questions are relevant and tied to the predefined criteria to maintain consistency.
Lack of interviewer training
Even the best-structured process won’t work if interviewers aren’t trained properly. Take the time to train your hiring team on how to conduct structured interviews and evaluate candidates using the rubric.
Final thoughts on structured interviews
Structured interviewing can transform your hiring process, helping your company save time, reduce costs, and improve your quality of hire. Yes, it requires a bit more planning upfront—but it enables you to create a smooth interview experience that results in better hiring outcomes.
Ready to streamline your hiring? See how JobScore can help.
