Skill Assessments: The Key to Efficient and Effective Hiring

Jen Dewar Avatar
skill assessments
The key to efficient and effective hiring

    Get talent acquisition best practices, trends, and news delivered directly to your inbox.

    Finding the right talent for your organization can feel like searching for a needle in a haystack. With a long list of candidates and only one job opening, hiring a qualified candidate means most employers are conducting four or more interviews over a 4-6 week period.

    What if there was a way to streamline your hiring process, save precious time and resources, and consistently identify qualified candidates?

    Enter skill assessments: the key to efficient and effective hiring.

    In this article, we’ll explore how skill assessments can transform your recruitment strategy and help you build a more competent, diverse, and successful workforce.

    What are skill assessments?

    Skill assessments are structured evaluation methods designed to measure a candidate’s abilities, knowledge, and aptitude for specific job-related tasks. By providing objective data on a candidate’s capabilities, skill assessments help you make more informed hiring decisions.

    Assessments can take various forms, including:

    • Technical tests, such as coding challenges and software proficiency exams

    • Situational judgment tests

    • Cognitive ability tests

    • Personality assessments

    • Job simulation exercises

    By incorporating skill assessments into your hiring process, you gain valuable insights into a candidate’s potential performance on the job, helping you identify top talent more efficiently and effectively.

    The benefits of using skill assessments in your hiring process

    Incorporating assessments into your recruitment strategy allows you to unlock a range of benefits that not only save time and resources but also improve your quality hire.

    1

    Improved candidate quality

    Skill assessments help you identify and focus on candidates who possess the specific abilities required for the job.

    This means:

    • Higher-quality applicants progressing through your hiring funnel

    • Increased likelihood of finding the right fit for your team

    • Better alignment between candidate skills and job requirements

    By using objective data to evaluate candidates, you’re more likely to find individuals who can hit the ground running and contribute to your organization’s success from day one. In fact, 56% of employers say that assessments improve their quality of hire.

    2

    Reduced bias in hiring

    Unconscious bias can creep into even the most well-intentioned hiring processes. 

    Skill assessments offer a more objective way to evaluate candidates by:

    • Focusing on abilities rather than background or demographics

    • Providing standardized evaluation criteria

    • Allowing for blind reviews of assessment results

    This approach can help you build a more diverse and inclusive workforce, as 59% of employers agree that assessments enable more fair, unbiased hiring decisions

    3

    Time and cost savings

    One of the most significant advantages of skill assessments is their ability to save you time. In fact, 44% of employers agree that assessments enable faster hiring.

    By quickly identifying candidates with the right skills and abilities, you can:

    • Reduce the number of interviews needed

    • Decrease time-to-hire

    • Lower recruitment costs

    • Minimize the risk of bad hires

    These time and cost savings can make a substantial impact on your bottom line.

    4

    Enhanced candidate experience

    Skill assessments can be a great way to improve the candidate experience when implemented thoughtfully. 

    Here’s how:

    • Candidates appreciate the opportunity to showcase their skills

    • Assessments provide a realistic preview of the job, helping candidates self-select

    • The process feels fair and transparent

    By offering a more engaging and relevant recruitment process, you’re more likely to attract and retain top talent throughout your recruitment funnel.

    5

    Data-driven decision making

    Relying on gut feelings for hiring decisions is no longer enough. 

    Skill assessments provide you with concrete data to:

    • Compare candidates objectively

    • Inform employee onboarding and training programs

    This wealth of information allows you to make more informed decisions not just during hiring, but throughout an employee’s tenure with your organization.

    Implementing skill assessments in your hiring process

    Now that we’ve explored the benefits of skill assessments, let’s look at how you can effectively incorporate them into your hiring strategy.

    1

    Identify the key skills for each role

    Before implementing any assessments, it’s crucial to:

    • Analyze job descriptions and requirements

    • Consult with team leaders and current top performers

    • Determine which skills are essential vs. nice-to-have

    This step ensures that your assessments are tailored to the specific needs of each role, providing you with the most relevant and valuable information.

    2

    Choose the right assessment 

    Plan your work assessment according to the skills you want to evaluate. For example, you might ask a communications candidate to write a press release, or a customer success candidate to do a role play that mimics real workplace situations.

    Keep assessments brief, as only 21% of candidates say they’d spend more than 20 minutes on it.

    Maximum time candidates would spend on a hiring assessment

    About a third of employers (32%) rely on assessment providers to support their interview process. With a plethora of assessment options available, selecting the right tools for your needs is essential. 

    Consider factors such as:

    • The types of skills you need to evaluate (technical, soft skills, cognitive abilities)

    • The level of customization required

    • ATS integration

    • Cost and scalability

    Many assessment platforms offer free trials or demos, so don’t hesitate to test a few options before making a decision.

    3

    Determine when to use assessments in your hiring process

    Skill assessments can be valuable at various stages of the recruitment process:

    • As an initial screening tool to screen applicants

    • After the first interview to dive deeper into candidates’ abilities

    • As part of a final round to compare top contenders

    The best timing may depend on things like the volume of applications you receive, your candidate churn rate, and candidate feedback. Experiment to find the sweet spot that works for your organization.

    4

    Communicate clearly with candidates

    Transparency is key when using skill assessments in your hiring process. 

    Be sure to:

    • Explain the purpose of the assessment

    • Provide clear instructions and expectations

    • Offer accommodations for candidates with disabilities

    • Share how the results will be used in the decision-making process

    Clear communication helps candidates feel more comfortable and prepared, leading to a better overall experience and more accurate results.

    5

    Analyze and act on the results

    Once you’ve gathered assessment data, it’s time to put it to use:

    • Establish benchmarks based on your top performers

    • Compare candidate results against these benchmarks

    • Look for patterns and insights across multiple assessments

    • Use the data to inform your interview questions and discussions

    Remember, skill assessments should be just one part of your overall evaluation process. Combine the results with interviews, reference checks, and other traditional hiring methods for a well-rounded view of each candidate.

    6

    Share assessment results with candidates

    If not selected for a job, 42% of candidates would like to receive the results of a hiring assessment

    Taking the time to share results can:

    • Improve your candidate experience

    • Offer transparency into hiring decisions

    • Help candidates improve their skill sets

    This wealth of information allows you to make more informed decisions not just during hiring, but throughout an employee’s tenure with your organization.

    Common challenges and how to overcome them

    While skill assessments offer numerous benefits, they’re not without their challenges.

    Here are some common obstacles you might face and strategies to overcome them:

    1

    Cost of assessments

    Budget is the most common challenge, with 45% of employers reporting cost as a barrier to using assessments in their hiring process.

    You can help justify the cost by exploring the risks of a poor candidate evaluation process:

    • The cost of a bad hire

    • The cost of your employee’s time to conduct an interview to assess skills instead

    • Legal costs associated with biased hiring decisions

    2

    Hiring speed

    Time-to-hire is the second most common challenge, with 38% of employers saying they don’t want assessment to slow down the recruitment process.

    To address this:

    • Reduce or eliminate other stages in the hiring process that don’t produce enough value to justify keeping them

    • Use assessments to enable faster decision-making—and get back to candidates quickly

    3

    Assessment accuracy

    Accuracy is another significant concern, with 27% of employers listing concerns about validity as a barrier to using assessments. Further, 70% cite accuracy or validity as the biggest concern when it comes to selecting a talent assessment to use.

    To address this:

    • Share data on the effectiveness of skill assessments

    • Start with a pilot program to demonstrate value

    • Involve key stakeholders in the selection and implementation process

    4

    Candidate dissatisfaction

    Nearly one in five employers (17%) say candidates don’t like assessments. This could lead to candidate churn and damage to your reputation.

    To mitigate this:

    • Keep assessments concise and relevant

    • Clearly communicate the value of the assessment to candidates

    • Compensate candidates for their time

    • Offer detailed assessment feedback so candidates understand their performance and how they can improve

    You can also challenge this assumption directly, as 70% of candidates agree that assessments help them demonstrate their potential.

    Final thoughts on embracing the power of skill assessments

    As you navigate the challenges of modern recruiting, consider how skill assessments can transform your hiring process and help you build the high-performing team your company needs to thrive.

    The key to success lies in choosing the right assessments for your needs, implementing them effectively, and using the results as part of a holistic evaluation process. With these strategies in place, you’ll be well on your way to revolutionizing your recruitment efforts and securing the talent that will drive your business forward.

    Want to learn more about streamlining your recruitment process? Learn how JobScore can help.