Subscribe for updates
Get talent acquisition best practices, trends, and news delivered directly to your inbox.
By entering your email, you agree to receive marketing emails from JobScore
Recruiting is one of the most critical functions for many organizations, but it’s also one of the most challenging. Limited resources, time constraints, and the need to compete with other companies for talent can make hiring a daunting task. Many organizations face high recruiting costs and inefficient processes, leading to lost opportunities and, at times, poor hiring decisions.
An optimized interview process can help you address many of these challenges. By streamlining the steps involved in recruiting, you can identify qualified candidates more effectively, reduce time spent on unnecessary interviews, and minimize recruiting costs. A well-structured interview process leads to better hiring outcomes, helping companies grow faster and more efficiently.
In this article, we’ll explore practical best practices that can help you create a more efficient and effective job interview process.
How to optimize your interview process for more successful outcomes
Building an effective interview process is crucial for finding skilled candidates quickly and efficiently. A well-structured process saves time, minimizes costs, and ensures that you’re hiring people who are not only qualified but also a good fit for your company culture.
82%
of recruiters have lost quality talent due to a poor interview process.
The thing is, an effective interview process may look a little different for each organization — and perhaps even for each role. Here’s how you can design an interview process that yields better hiring outcomes.
Step 1: Define the role and create an ideal candidate profile
It’s essential to clearly define the role and build an ideal candidate profile before beginning interviews. These are important steps to craft a clear job description that outlines specific responsibilities and skills required for the role. Doing so not only helps you attract the right candidates, it also helps your team calibrate on what a qualified candidate looks like.
Step 2: Align job requirements with appropriate evaluation methods
Next, consider how you can best evaluate each candidate’s skills as they relate to your job requirements. For example, you might use a work assignment to evaluate a candidate’s hard skills, a behavioral interview to assess their soft skills, and a reference check to gauge their leadership abilities.
Plan out how you’ll use each method, including the specific tools you’ll use and interview questions you’ll ask.
Over 50%
of employers make candidates go through four or more interviews, and have a process that lasts four to six weeks.
Step 3: Build your interview process around the role’s needs
Once your evaluation methods are in place, it’s time to structure the interview process accordingly. Too many organizations make the mistake of dragging out the interview process with multiple stages, which can result in losing top candidates to competitors.
Consider how many interviews you’ll need based on your evaluation criteria and which of your team members are best suited to make accurate assessments. For example, if the hiring manager can evaluate each of the role’s required skills, a single in-person interview should suffice. You can always add a lunch interview if you want to get a sign off from anyone else on your team or give your candidate the opportunity to meet other team members. But if you’re hiring for a cross-functional role and need input from other departments, it may make sense to have several in-person interviews or a panel interview.
Common stages in the interview process
Every company has different needs, but many follow similar stages in their interview processes. Let’s review some of the most common interview stages and how they can be optimized to best meet your needs.
Recruiter screening interview
The initial screening interview is often conducted by a recruiter to narrow down the applicant pool before candidates meet other members of the hiring team. It’s typically a 30 minute phone interview or video interview to quickly review each candidate’s qualifications and help ensure that those moving on meet the minimum requirements for the role.
Similarly, candidates may use this opportunity to gauge whether they want to invest their time in your recruiting process. Make sure to learn about each candidate’s motivations so you can sell them on the perks of working at your company — and leave time for your candidates to ask their own questions. If the candidate asks a question you don’t know the answer to, find out and follow up if you can.
Hiring manager screening interview
A phone or virtual interview with the hiring manager may be done instead of, or in addition to, a recruiter screen. The hiring manager may try to determine whether the candidate has basic qualifications, enthusiasm for the position, and alignment with company culture before asking additional team members to invest their time in the hiring process.
The hiring manager screen also presents an opportunity for the candidate to learn more about their potential supervisor, the impact of the role, and the team dynamic. This makes the hiring manger screening interview a worthwhile way to assess mutual fit before investing time into more in-depth interviews.
Skill assessment
Skill assessments allow you to evaluate a candidate’s technical abilities and soft skills. These assessments can take the form of written tests, coding challenges, or personality tests, depending on the role.
They may be offered either before or after in-person interviews to help you quickly identify if a candidate possesses the core competencies necessary to succeed. Just try to keep them brief: Only 21% of candidates say they’d spend more than 20 minutes on an assessment. You may want to consider compensating candidates for their time if your assessments are longer than that.
56%
of talent acquisition professionals say assessments help them hire higher quality candidates.
In-depth interviews
In-depth interviews have traditionally taken place onsite, but it’s become increasingly common for them to be conducted virtually. Giving candidates the choice offers greater flexibility for them to best represent themselves and better balance the recruitment process with their other responsibilities.
The number of in-depth interviews can vary depending on the role and the size of your team. It’s crucial to determine which team members are best suited to assess different aspects of the candidate’s qualifications, and structure the interview accordingly.
For example, you might begin with a hiring manger interview to welcome the candidate, assess a couple key soft skills, and answer candidate questions. A team member may come next to evaluate one or two technical skills and provide the candidate with another perspective on the role, team, and organization. Finally, a company leader might meet the candidate to help ensure culture-add and answer high-level questions about the organization. Having a clear role for each interviewer can help reduce redundant interview questions and eliminate unnecessary stages in the interview process.
Similarly, the way you format interviews can help you reduce individual stages. For example, a virtual interview can be recorded and played back for additional people to weigh in on candidate responses, and a panel interview can allow multiple team members to meet a candidate at once.
Lunch interview
The lunch interview is often used as a more informal stage, allowing the candidate and team members to get to know each other in a relaxed setting. Of course, lunch can be replaced with coffee, dinner, a walk, or anything else that best suits your team and candidate.
While not necessary for every hire, this interview type can be particularly helpful when assessing cultural fit or giving the candidate a better understanding of the company environment.
Provide a positive candidate experience by discussing options and specifics ahead of time. For example, ensure the candidate likes the cuisine type and can be accommodated for food allergies.
Best practices for a successful interview process
A successful interview process requires more than just setting up meetings. Here are some best practices you can follow to engage top candidates and make more informed hiring decisions.
1
Schedule interviews quickly
More than half of candidates (55%) will give up on the interview process if they don’t schedule their first interview within a week of submitting their application.
Review applications and shortlist candidates quickly so you don’t keep them waiting. Using an interview scheduling email template with candidate self-scheduling options can help you streamline your process and meet with candidates faster.
2
Offer accommodations
Offer reasonable accommodations during interviews, such as sign language interpreters or accessible interview spaces. This is an important way to ensure all candidates can participate fully and perform at their best.
3
Train your interviewers
Ensure that your interviewers are trained not only in assessing candidates’ technical and behavioral skills but also in creating a welcoming interview environment and avoiding unconscious biases. This helps foster fairness and ensures that every candidate gets an equal opportunity.
4
Prepare candidates for interviews
Send an interview confirmation email to make sure candidates know the logistics of their upcoming interview, such as where to go, who they’ll meet, and what format will be used.
Consider sharing the interview agenda or questions ahead of time to help candidates feel more confident and well-prepared. Clear communication reduces anxiety and improves the overall candidate experience.
5
Create a welcoming interview environment
First impressions matter. Greet candidates warmly, introduce them to the interviewers, and explain the structure of the interview. A friendly and transparent environment sets the tone for a productive interview and helps candidates feel comfortable.
6
Use structured interviews
It can be difficult to compare candidates and select the most qualified one if you’re using different qualification criteria for each.
Ask every candidate the same question, in the same order, to ensure you can rate them all on the same criteria.
7
Give candidates time to ask their own questions
Candidates appreciate the opportunity to ask questions, and it can provide valuable insight into their priorities and concerns. Make sure to allocate time for candidates to ask their questions, as this signals that you value their input.
8
Make quick, data-driven decisions
The faster you make decisions, the less likely you are to lose top candidates to other offers. Collect interviewer feedback promptly, use a data-driven approach to evaluate responses, and make decisions swiftly. A streamlined decision-making process shows candidates that your company is efficient and serious about hiring.
9
Follow-up after interviews
No candidate wants to be left in the dark after an interview. Keep candidates informed of their status, communicate the next steps, and provide feedback. This improves your candidate experience, reflecting well on your employer brand.
10
Make continuous improvement
After each round of hiring, take the time to analyze your interview process and identify areas for improvement.
Key metrics such as time-to-hire, interview-to-offer ratio, and candidate satisfaction can provide valuable insights into how well your process is working — and where there are opportunities for improvement.
Final thoughts on optimizing your interview process
A streamlined interview process isn’t just a matter of saving time — it’s a competitive advantage. By reducing the time-to-hire, cutting down unnecessary stages, and improving your candidate experience, companies can not only attract better talent but also reduce overall recruiting costs.
JobScore can help you optimize your interview process for better hiring outcomes with seamless scheduling, comprehensive interview templates, and actionable reports. See these features in action with a free trial.
Learn how to optimize your interview process with JobScore.
