Subscribe for updates
Get talent acquisition best practices, trends, and news delivered directly to your inbox.
By entering your email, you agree to receive marketing emails from JobScore
Finding the right talent for your team is critical to your company’s success, but the recruitment process can be time-consuming and challenging. This is where external recruiters can become valuable partners in your talent acquisition strategy.
External recruiters are recruiting professionals from outside your organization who you contract with to find and screen candidates for specific roles or industries. They strategically source, engage, and present candidates who are open to new opportunities.
These third-party recruiting professionals can be particularly useful when you need to fill hard-to-fill positions, hire for executive-level roles, or when you need to bring talent on board quickly.
Types of external recruiters
There are several different recruitment agency models and many different specializations.
Agency models include:
Specializations include:
Advantages of working with external recruiters
Partnering with external recruiters can provide numerous benefits that help streamline your hiring process, save time, and connect you with high-quality candidates who might otherwise be inaccessible.
Specialized expertise and industry knowledge
External recruiters often develop deep expertise in specific industries, functions, or geographic regions. This specialization allows them to understand the nuances of the talent market in ways that generalist internal recruiters might not. They know the going rates for different roles, which skills are in highest demand, and how to evaluate candidates effectively for specific positions.
A specialist recruiter who works exclusively with marketing professionals, for example, will understand the differences between a growth marketer and a brand marketer, know which skills are most important for each role, and have connections with professionals across the marketing landscape. This expertise enables them to quickly identify candidates who not only have the right skills but also the right experience for your specific needs.
Access to a broader candidate pool
One of the most valuable benefits external recruiters provide is access to a wider talent pool, including passive candidates who aren’t actively job searching but might be open to the right opportunity.
External recruiters maintain extensive professional networks and candidate databases built over years of relationship-building. They have existing connections with qualified professionals and can tap into their networks quickly when you have an open position. These relationships often give them access to hidden candidates who aren’t responding to job postings or submitting applications through traditional channels.
Time savings in the hiring process
The recruitment process involves numerous time-consuming activities: Writing job descriptions, posting to job boards, reviewing resumes, conducting initial screenings, coordinating interviews, checking references, and more.
External recruiters handle much of this work for you, particularly in the early stages of the process. They manage the initial sourcing and screening, ensuring that you only spend time reviewing and interviewing pre-qualified candidates who match your requirements. This efficiency can significantly reduce your time-to-hire metrics.
Enhanced candidate vetting
External recruiters don’t just find candidates — they thoroughly vet them before presenting them to you. This vetting process typically includes evaluating technical skills, assessing cultural fit, checking references, and discussing salary expectations. By the time you review a candidate, the recruiter has already determined that they meet your key requirements.
This pre-screening process means you’ll typically need to review fewer candidates overall. This focused approach helps ensure you’re spending your valuable time with candidates who have a genuine chance of success in the role.
Market insights and salary benchmarking
External recruiters have their finger on the pulse of the job market and can provide valuable insights about compensation trends, available talent, and competitive factors that might affect your hiring strategy. They can help you set realistic expectations about the candidates you’re likely to attract and the compensation package you’ll need to offer.
A strong recruiting partner will let you know if your salary range is below market or if your requirements are too restrictive given the available talent pool. This intelligence allows you to make informed adjustments to your hiring strategy, potentially saving you weeks or months of fruitless searching.
Flexibility for fluctuating hiring needs
Most businesses don’t hire at a constant rate throughout the year. You might experience periods of rapid growth followed by hiring freezes or have seasonal fluctuations in your recruiting needs. External recruiters provide flexible support that can scale up or down based on your current requirements.
This flexibility is often more cost-effective than maintaining a large internal recruiting team that might be underutilized during slower periods. You can engage external recruiters only when you need them, allowing you to optimize your recruiting budget while still maintaining access to talent when necessary.
Confidential search capabilities
There are times when you need to conduct a search with discretion, such as when replacing an underperforming executive or exploring a new strategic direction before announcing it publicly. External recruiters can operate with anonymity, allowing you to keep sensitive searches confidential.
They provide a buffer when recruiting from competitors or customers, approaching candidates without revealing your company identity until appropriate. This confidentiality can be invaluable for maintaining business relationships and managing internal dynamics during sensitive transitions.
Drawbacks of working with external recruiters
While external recruiters offer many advantages, there are also potential drawbacks to consider. Understanding these challenges can help you make an informed decision about whether and how to work with recruitment agencies.
Cost considerations
Perhaps the most obvious drawback is the cost. External recruiters typically charge significant fees, usually calculated as a percentage of the hired candidate’s first-year salary. For contingency recruiters, these fees typically range from 15-30% of the base salary, while retained search firms may charge 30-35% of the total compensation package.
This expense can be significant, especially for organizations with tight budgets. It’s important to consider the value of time saved, access to passive candidates, and the potential cost of a bad hire or an extended vacancy when weighing these costs.
Potential misalignment with company culture
External recruiters work with multiple clients simultaneously and may not fully understand the unique aspects of your company culture, work environment, and team dynamics. Without this deep understanding, they might send candidates who have the right skills but aren’t a good cultural fit for your organization.
This misalignment can lead to higher turnover or performance issues down the line.
Less direct control over candidate communication
The agency recruiter typically serves as the primary point of contact for candidates throughout much of the early recruiting process. This arrangement gives you less control over what information is shared with candidates and how your company is portrayed.
If a recruiter misrepresents job responsibilities, company benefits, or growth opportunities, it can lead to misunderstandings or disappointment after a candidate is hired. Additionally, candidates may not receive the consistent messaging about your company’s mission, values, and culture that they would get from an internal recruiter who lives and breathes your organization’s ethos daily.
Variable quality across agencies and individual recruiters
Not all external recruiters are created equal. The quality of service can vary dramatically between agencies and even between individual recruiters within the same agency. Some will take the time to understand your needs deeply and present well-matched candidates, while others might take a more transactional approach, focusing on filling positions quickly rather than finding the best fit.
This variability means that finding the right recruiting partner can require significant time and effort on your part. You may need to try multiple agencies before finding one that consistently presents high-quality candidates who meet your standards.
Risk of duplicate candidate submissions
When working with multiple recruiting agencies, there’s a risk of receiving the same candidate from different sources. This situation can create complications regarding “candidate ownership” and determining which agency is entitled to the placement fee if you hire that person.
These conflicts can strain your relationships with recruiting partners and potentially lead to legal disputes if not handled properly. Clear agreements about candidate ownership and a system for tracking submissions can help mitigate this risk, but it remains a common challenge when engaging multiple agencies simultaneously.
Potential for misaligned incentives
Most external recruiters work on a commission basis, earning money only when you hire their candidates. This incentive structure can sometimes create a focus on making placements rather than finding the best long-term fit for your organization. Some recruiters might encourage you to move quickly on candidates before you’ve completed a thorough evaluation process, or they might downplay candidate weaknesses to get the placement.
It’s important to find recruiting partners who take a consultative approach and are willing to give honest feedback about candidates, even if it means losing a potential placement. The best recruiters understand that their long-term success depends on making successful placements that benefit both the client and the candidate.
Best practices for working with external recruiters
To maximize the benefits of working with external recruiters while minimizing the potential drawbacks, consider implementing these best practices in your approach.
Select the right recruiting partners
With no shortage of recruiting agencies to choose from, finding the right partners is crucial. Start by looking for agencies that specialize in your industry or the specific functions you’re hiring for. A specialist will understand the nuances of the roles you’re trying to fill and have connections with relevant candidates.
Begin with agencies or recruiters you’ve worked with successfully in the past, either as an employer or as a candidate. If you don’t have personal experience to draw from, ask colleagues for recommendations and check online reviews.
Once you’ve created a shortlist, interview each agency to understand their process, specializations, and track record. Ask about their time to first submission, submission-to-interview ratio, fill rate, and fee structure. Also, learn about who will be your main point of contact and the roles of anyone else who will work on your account.
Finally, speak with references from each agency. Ask to connect with another client who has filled similar roles for a similar type of company. Confirm what you learned during the agency interview and ask for advice on how to work effectively with the agency.
Develop strong, focused relationships
Rather than spreading your efforts across numerous agencies, focus on building strong relationships with a few trusted partners. Working with too many agencies at once can create several problems: It takes time to share information and manage multiple relationships, you may get overwhelmed with candidate submissions, and some agencies might lose interest if they know they’re competing with many others.
Limit yourself to working with no more than three agencies for any given position. This approach allows you to focus your efforts and gives each agency a fair chance at filling the role. Over time, a smaller number of agencies will develop a deeper understanding of your company culture, hiring needs, and preferences, leading to better matches and a more efficient process.
Create clear, formal agreements
Before beginning a search, establish a formal agreement that outlines the key terms of your relationship with the recruiting agency.
Your agreement should cover:
Having these terms clearly defined from the outset prevents misunderstandings and disputes later in the process.
Conduct thorough intake meetings
Start each search with a comprehensive intake or kickoff meeting to align expectations with your recruiting partner. This meeting is crucial for helping the agency understand exactly what you’re looking for and how to position your opportunity to candidates.
During the intake meeting, provide a detailed overview of your company and the role, including “pitch points” that would make a candidate excited about the opportunity. Discuss company culture, the position’s impact on the organization, the team they’d be joining, and specific projects or initiatives they’d be working on. Also share any potential challenges or drawbacks of the role to ensure candidates have realistic expectations.
Develop a detailed ideal candidate profile that goes beyond the job description. Specify required versus desired qualifications, target companies or schools, and the reasons you might reject a candidate. Be open to a candid discussion about whether your expectations are realistic given market conditions and what your company can offer.
Review your interview process so the agency understands each step and timeline. A great agency may offer suggestions to improve your process based on their experience with other clients.
Finally, explore a few sample candidates together to calibrate your expectations and help the agency understand your preferences.
Maintain consistent, responsive communication
Effective communication is the foundation of a successful relationship with external recruiters. Commit to communicating with your agency partners at least two or three times each week during active searches, and provide prompt feedback on candidates they submit.
Without timely feedback, you’ll likely see candidate submissions dry up. Agencies use your feedback to refine their searches and pass information along to candidates in the recruitment process. Delayed feedback not only slows your hiring process but can also lead to losing strong candidates who accept other offers while waiting to hear back.
Be specific in your feedback. Rather than simply saying a candidate isn’t a fit, explain why. This information helps recruiters adjust their search criteria and better understand your preferences. The more specific you can be about what you liked and didn’t like about each candidate, the better the next round of submissions will be.
Set clear expectations for candidate experience
Your recruiting partners represent your company to potential employees, so it’s essential to set clear expectations for how they should interact with candidates.
Discuss expectations for candidate communication, including how quickly the agency should respond to candidate inquiries, how they should present information about your company, and how they’ll keep candidates informed about their status in the process. A positive candidate experience reflects well on your company and helps build your employer brand, even among candidates who don’t ultimately join your team.
Provide thorough, accurate job information
Give your recruiting partners the information they need to represent your opportunities accurately. This includes not only the job description and requirements but also details about your company culture, team dynamics, growth opportunities, and benefits package.
A full 61% of candidates prioritize compensation and benefits when considering a new job. Make sure your recruiting partners have current market data to ensure your roles are competitively priced. If your offers consistently fall short of market rates, you’ll struggle to attract top talent regardless of how effective your recruiters are.
Be transparent about any challenges or potential drawbacks of the role or your company. It’s better to address these issues upfront than to have new hires discover them after joining and potentially leave as a result. A good recruiter can help frame challenges in a positive light while still giving candidates an accurate picture of what to expect.
Streamline your interview process
The best candidates may not be on the market for long, so having an efficient interview process is crucial. Work with your recruiting partners to create a streamlined process that allows you to thoroughly evaluate candidates without unnecessary delays or redundant steps.
Share your interview process with recruiters so they can communicate it clearly to candidates. Include the number of interviews, who candidates will meet with at each stage, and your typical timeline from first interview to offer. This transparency helps set expectations and keeps candidates engaged throughout the process.
Consider the recruiter’s feedback on your process. Experienced recruiters have seen what works and what doesn’t across multiple companies and can offer valuable suggestions for improvement. They can help you identify bottlenecks, redundancies, or steps that might be causing candidate churn.
Manage candidate ownership efficiently
When working with multiple recruiting sources, including internal referrals and direct applications, it’s essential to have a system for tracking candidate sources and managing ownership. Use an applicant tracking system that checks for duplicate submissions and maintains clear records of which recruiter submitted each candidate first.
When duplicate submissions occur, promptly alert the agencies involved to avoid disputes later. Modern applicant tracking systems can automatically detect duplicates based on email addresses or other identifying information, making this process more manageable.
Be transparent with your recruiting partners about your policies for handling candidate ownership. Clear guidelines prevent misunderstandings and help maintain positive relationships with your recruiting partners.
Final thoughts on partnering with external recruiters
External recruiters can be valuable partners in your talent acquisition strategy, offering specialized expertise, access to passive candidates, time savings, and market insights that might be difficult to develop internally. However, realizing these benefits requires a thoughtful approach to selecting and working with recruiting agencies.
Remember that the most successful relationships with external recruiters are collaborative rather than transactional. Treat your recruiters as strategic partners rather than vendors, and invest time in helping them understand your business, culture, and hiring needs. This investment will pay dividends in the form of better-qualified candidates, faster placements, and ultimately stronger teams.
Working with external recruiters isn’t just about filling current openings — it’s about building relationships that support your company’s growth and talent needs over time. With the right approach and partners, external recruiters can become a powerful extension of your hiring team, helping you secure the talent you need to achieve your business objectives.
