Panel Interviews: Advantages, Drawbacks, and Best Practices

Subscribe for updates

Get talent acquisition best practices, trends, and news delivered directly to your inbox.

By entering your email, you agree to receive marketing emails from JobScore

Finding and securing top talent requires a strategic and efficient hiring process. You need to properly evaluate candidates to ensure a high quality of hire, while providing an engaging candidate experience. Panel interviews can help.

A panel interview is a hiring technique where multiple interviewers simultaneously meet with a job candidate. They can be a powerful tool for thoroughly assessing candidates while streamlining the recruitment process.

This comprehensive guide will walk you through everything you need to know about implementing successful panel interviews at your organization.

Benefits of panel interviews

Understanding the advantages of panel interviews can help you determine if this format aligns with your hiring goals and organizational needs. Here are the key benefits that make panel interviews an attractive option for many companies.

Time efficiency

Panel interviews significantly reduce the total number of interview days needed by consolidating multiple interviews into one session. This streamlined approach minimizes schedule disruptions and accelerates the decision-making process.

The format simplifies scheduling logistics by reducing coordination requirements and calendar conflicts. Companies can accelerate their hiring timeline through faster feedback collection and quicker consensus building.

Candidates benefit from reduced fatigue since they face fewer separate interviews and avoid repeating answers to similar questions.

Better evaluation

Panel interviews provide multiple perspectives on each candidate by bringing together diverse expertise and experience levels. This approach can reduce individual bias through balanced decision making and multiple evaluator input.

The format enables comprehensive skill assessment by combining technical capability validation with soft skills evaluation and cultural fit assessment. Organizations can maintain consistent comparison across candidates through standardized evaluation criteria and uniform interview structure.

Improved candidate experience

Candidates benefit from a single comprehensive session that provides exposure to multiple team members simultaneously. This format offers deeper insight into company culture through interaction with various stakeholders.

The efficiency of the process demonstrates respect for the candidate’s time and professional commitments. Candidates receive more consistent information about the role and company since all interviewers are present to hear and contribute to responses.

Cost effectiveness

Organizations save on recruitment costs by reducing the number of separate interviews required. The consolidated format decreases coordination overhead and administrative burden.

Companies see a lower risk of poor hiring decisions due to multiple perspectives in the evaluation process. The decreased time-to-hire helps organizations secure top talent before competitors and reduces the cost of prolonged vacancies.

Drawbacks and challenges of panel interviews

While panel interviews offer many benefits, organizations should be aware of potential challenges that need to be managed effectively.

Coordination complexities

Scheduling multiple interviewers requires careful coordination of busy calendars and competing priorities. Maintaining consistent attendance can be challenging when urgent business needs arise. Managing different departmental priorities often requires advance planning and clear communication. The format demands significant preparation time from all panel members to ensure effective participation.

Candidate intimidation

The panel format can create a more stressful environment for some candidates who might feel overwhelmed. Building natural rapport becomes more challenging with multiple interviewers present simultaneously. Some candidates may experience increased anxiety that impacts their interview performance. The formal nature of panel interviews might prevent some candidates from showing their authentic selves.

Group dynamics

Strong personalities on the panel may inadvertently influence other interviewers’ opinions. The risk of groupthink can emerge when panel members hesitate to disagree with colleagues. Managing panel discussion requires skilled facilitation to ensure balanced participation. Different interviewing styles among panel members might send mixed messages to candidates.

When to use panel interviews

Panel interviews can be an effective way to evaluate candidates, but they don’t necessarily need to be a mainstay in your recruitment process. It’s important to consider how each interview technique can best help you evaluate candidates.

Panel interviews can be particularly useful in the following situations:

You want to reduce the number of stages in your interview process. More than half of employers say their interview process consists of four or more interviews, and lasts four to six weeks. A panel interview is a great way to consolidate the stages in your interview process without eliminating stakeholders from the decision-making process.
The candidate will work in a cross-functional role. One-on-one interviews generally provide a better candidate experience when each interviewer asks a unique set of questions, but there may be times when you want every interviewer to hear the candidate’s responses. Panel interviews allow multiple people on your hiring team to evaluate candidate responses and ask follow-up questions, without repeating questions in multiple interviews.
The role’s requirements include meeting with several stakeholders simultaneously. Some roles, such as those in sales and leadership, may require strong communication and persuasion skills in large meetings. A panel interview is a great way to see those skills in action.
You’re training interviewers. Interviewer training is crucial to ensure that your team members have the skills and knowledge to fairly, accurately, and efficiently assess candidates. Panel interviews are a great time to put the training into practice with a more experienced interviewer present.
You’re conducting lunch interviews. Lunch interviews are typically more casual, unstructured opportunities for you to get to know a candidate better—and for them to get to know you. This works well as a panel interview so your candidates can get a well-rounded view of your team—and your team members can feel involved in the decision-making process.

Who should be on your interview panel?

Panel interviews typically bring together 3-5 stakeholders, but the number and roles of interviewers should be chosen according to your unique needs.

For example, a panel interview for a cross-functional role might include a team member from each relevant department. But a junior-level role may only include the hiring manager and a team member.

Selecting the right combination of interviewers that represent different aspects of the role and organization can help ensure your panel’s success.

Panel members might include:

Hiring manager: The hiring manager leads the overall hiring process and provides crucial insight into role expectations and team dynamics. They evaluate management style fit and professional goals throughout the interview. As the ultimate decision maker, they incorporate panel input to make final hiring decisions.
Team representative: A team representative offers valuable perspective on the daily work environment and assesses technical skills and team compatibility. They share detailed insights about team culture and workflow patterns. Their role includes evaluating potential peer relationships and how the candidate might integrate into existing team dynamics.
HR representative: The HR representative ensures compliance with hiring regulations while assessing cultural fit and soft skills. They manage sensitive compensation discussions and coordinate the entire interview process. Their presence helps maintain consistency across hiring practices and ensures all legal requirements are met.
Department head: The department head provides strategic perspective on how the role fits into broader organizational goals. They evaluate leadership potential and assess cross-functional capabilities. Their involvement offers candidates insight into career growth opportunities within the organization.
Project stakeholder: Project stakeholders evaluate collaboration abilities by assessing how candidates might impact ongoing projects. They provide insight into cross-team dynamics and help identify potential challenges and opportunities. Their perspective helps ensure the candidate can work effectively across organizational boundaries.
Executive team member: Executive team members evaluate alignment with company vision and assess leadership capabilities at a higher level. They provide strategic perspective on organizational direction and ensure cultural alignment at senior levels. Their presence signals the importance of the role to candidates.

How to structure an effective interview panel

A well-structured panel interview is essential for maximizing its effectiveness while ensuring a positive candidate experience. This begins well before the interview takes place—and extends well after.

Before the interview

Investing in pre-interview preparation helps your panel run smoothly for your team members and provide a positive interview experience for your candidates.

Define the job requirements, including the the necessary skills, qualifications, and traits required for success
Develop interview questions that can be used to assess candidates for your must-have skills, qualifications, and traits
Design a scoring rubric to objectively evaluate candidate responses to each interview question
Define roles for each interviewer to ensure your team evaluates must-have skills while preventing redundant questions
Create an interview plan by combining the job requirements, interview questions, and scoring rubric together in a document that can guide your team members
Communicate with candidates so they understand the format of the interview and who they’ll be meeting

During the interview

Interviews aren’t just an opportunity for your team to assess candidates—they’re an opportunity for your candidates to assess your team and organization. It’s important to make time for both—even if that means extending the length of your panel.

Opening (5-10 minutes): Begin with a warm welcome where each panel member introduces themselves, sharing their name, role, and connection to the position. Provide a clear explanation of the interview format, including the timeline and structure of the session, and why notes are being taken.
Core questions (30-45 minutes): Use the interview plan to guide the conversation, taking notes that can be referenced later. Each interviewer should focus on their assigned area of expertise while maintaining a conversational flow.
Candidate questions (10-15 minutes): Allow time for candidates to ask their own questions. It’s important to provide a realistic picture of the role and company to help candidates assess fit.
Closing (5 minutes): Review your interview process timeline, sharing when your candidate will hear back and what to expect for next steps. End with a professional and encouraging tone, regardless of initial impressions.

After the interview

Leave time after the interview to write up evaluations and debrief with the hiring team.

Formal evaluation: Each interviewer should complete individual assessments soon after the interview, while the experience is still fresh in everyone’s mind. Include skill ratings, specific examples from the interview, and any concerns or reservations about the candidate’s fit or abilities.
Conduct a group debrief: After individual assessments are completed, hold a discussion comparing interviewer ratings and building consensus around the candidate’s qualifications and next steps.
Follow up with candidates: Get back to candidates when you say you will, even if it’s just to say that you haven’t made a decision yet. Following up with candidates is crucial for a positive candidate experience.

Final thoughts on panel interviews

Panel interviews represent a powerful tool in modern recruitment when properly structured and executed. Their ability to streamline the hiring process while providing comprehensive candidate evaluation can be a great way to identify and secure skilled talent.

But it’s important to remember that every interview isn’t necessarily suited for a panel. Use them when it makes sense for your role and organization, and refine your process based on feedback and results. Continuous improvement is the best way to improve your hiring outcomes.